Ep 5 "The Look Out" feels like a missed opportunity – a case that should have been tense and layered instead comes across as weakly plotted and disjointed.
The premise of a robbery gone wrong tied to a local football rivalry has potential, but the execution lacks depth. The investigation meanders, with the "lookout" angle feeling underdeveloped and the resolution arriving more out of convenience than clever detective work. Even the parallel subplot involving Angie and Ormewood's realtor murder case, while darker, doesn't quite elevate the episode. Ramón Rodríguez and Ione Skye remain watchable, but the writing fails to give them material worthy of their talents.
There's a filler episode vibe here, with the personal drama (Will and Angie's relationship, Faith's growing frustrations) doing more heavy lifting than the actual mystery. It's watchable, but lacks the tight pacing and emotional punch of stronger entries in the series. The episode's saving grace is its watchability… the cast keeps it from being a total dud, but the script doesn't do them any favors.
6/10: A forgettable detour in an otherwise promising season.
Where to watch
Checked 20 November 2026 for Season 1. US season listings and the official Hulu page confirm subscription access. UK season listings and the official Disney+ UK page list Season 1. India season listings show JioHotstar, whose official page lists four seasons and Season 1 Episode 1. Playback, plan entitlements and language options were not tested. Others opens JustWatch; choose your country.
