I found this to be a beautifully made episode with a deep emotional core, but I struggled to look past a few glaring logic gaps.
On one hand, the mystery is genuinely moving, and the 1930s atmosphere is captured with real soul. However, the premise feels a bit impractical; it's hard to believe a police department would pour this many resources into a 70-year-old case without a more pressing legal reason.
I also found the "orphan" storyline a bit distracting – despite being on their own during the Great Depression, the brother and sister are somehow wealthy enough to have two cars at home.
If you can ignore those plot holes, it's a good watch for the performances alone, but for me, those details held it back to a 6.5/10.
Where to watch
UK
Streaming availability unverifiedChecked 19 November 2026. US: JustWatch lists all seven seasons free with ads on The Roku Channel; the link opens a Season 1 episode with the show selector. UK: the current regional listing shows no local streaming option, so availability is unverified. India: the current regional listing shows all seven seasons with a Prime Video subscription; the provider link opens Season 1. Official Prime pages may change by region. These are title links, not direct playback. Playback and account entitlement were not tested. Availability can change. Others opens JustWatch; choose your country.
