Alfred Hitchcock Presents: S1.E8 Our Cook’s a Treasure

Arsenic With A Smile

B52 rating: 7.5/10

Alfred Hitchcock Presents poster

A neat, unpretentious little mystery that knows exactly what it's doing and does it well.

Ralph Montgomery is the kind of comfortably oblivious husband who wouldn't notice a storm brewing in his own kitchen – and that's precisely the point. The episode builds its paranoia around a genuinely clever red herring, letting the audience follow Ralph down entirely the wrong path with just enough plausibility to keep you convinced.

Everett Sloane is quietly excellent throughout, and Beulah Bondi as the suspect cook brings just the right amount of ambiguity to keep you guessing. But it's that final scene that earns the episode its place among the season's better entries – understated, perfectly timed, and leaving just enough unsaid to hit harder than any explicit ending could. Dorothy Sayers would have approved. 7.5/10.

Where to watch

Checked 18 November 2026. Peacock has an official Season 1 episode listing in the US. Sky officially lists the 1955 series and Season 1 on Sky Arts in the UK; access depends on your TV package. Regional catalogues disagree on UK streaming plans, so no subscription entitlement is promised. No current India title-specific option was verified. Account access and playback were not tested. Availability can change.