Alfred Hitchcock Presents: S1.E26 Whodunit

Even Dead, He Had To Know Who Did It

B52 rating: 7.5/10

Alfred Hitchcock Presents poster

Whodunit is one of the most genuinely original concepts the season has produced – a murdered mystery writer granted special dispensation from a celestial bureaucrat to return to earth and solve his own killing.

Hitchcock's introduction sets the tone beautifully, and the first half delivers on every promise the premise makes. The dry British wit crackles throughout, and John Williams is perfectly cast as the pompous, fussy Arlington – a man so consumed by his own self-importance that even death can't deflate him. Alan Napier as the Recording Angel is an absolute delight.

The problem is the second half – the suspects feel colourless, the gathering-of-clues loses momentum, and the payoff doesn't quite match the heightened expectations the opening creates.

7.5/10: A genuinely novel idea that deserved a sharper final act. Still thoroughly enjoyable – just slightly frustrating in hindsight.

Where to watch

Checked 18 November 2026. Peacock has an official Season 1 episode listing in the US. Sky officially lists the 1955 series and Season 1 on Sky Arts in the UK; access depends on your TV package. Regional catalogues disagree on UK streaming plans, so no subscription entitlement is promised. No current India title-specific option was verified. Account access and playback were not tested. Availability can change.