Poirot (1989): S6.E4 Dumb Witness

Bob Knows Best

B52 rating: 7.5/10

Poirot (1989) poster

Bob the dog is easily one of the highlights of this episode, but the mystery itself is just as enjoyable. Dumb Witness takes a few liberties with the original book, yet the adaptation works well on its own terms.

The story keeps shifting suspicion between Emily Arundel's relatives, with motives and clues gradually falling into place. Even when you think you have a handle on things, there is enough uncertainty to keep you guessing until Poirot finally lays everything out.

David Suchet is, as usual, excellent as Poirot, bringing his familiar precision and quiet confidence to the investigation. The supporting cast also gives the family tensions enough weight to make the suspects interesting.

Bob adds a lovely touch of charm, and his role in the mystery is more important than it first appears. I did feel that the connection between Poirot and the dog could have been explained a little better, but that is a minor flaw in an otherwise solid episode.

7.5/10: A well-played mystery with a genuinely memorable canine star.

Where to watch

Checked 20 November 2026. BritBox lists the complete collection in the US. UK season-specific listings identify ITVX free-with-ads / Premium and Netflix subscription access. India season 6: SonyLIV subscription listed. Availability varies by season, region and plan. Playback and account entitlements were not tested. Others opens JustWatch; choose your country.