A Bully, a Donation Bin and a Familiar Face
B52 rating: 7/10

Filed under: TV Episodes
Comedy · Romance · USA · 2011 · Watched on: HBO Max
I thought this was a good, funny and quite relatable episode. I liked how both storylines dealt with bullying from different angles, with Leonard confronting someone from his past while Penny tries to make amends for her own behaviour.
The girls' visit to the donation bin was easily my favourite part, especially how their good intentions gradually turned into a shopping spree! The Leonard and Jimmy storyline was also entertaining, although I could see where it was heading in the second half.
Lance Barber was particularly good as Jimmy. It's amusing to see him here as Leonard's school bully, knowing that he would later become Sheldon's dad in Young Sheldon.
7/10: A solid episode with some good laughs.
Where to watch
Checked 16 November 2026. Official HBO Max has a Season 5 guide but displayed a country availability warning on this check. JustWatch UK lists HBO Max Amazon Channel, which is a separate paid channel, plus purchase offers. JustWatch India lists Amazon Prime Video including an ad-supported plan. Operator and regional playback access were not verified; select the episode named above. These are title or availability pages, not direct playback. Local account entitlement, episode, language and cut were not tested. Confirm the exact offer before paying. Tracker viewing history is separate from current offers. Others opens JustWatch; choose your country.